Why is The Rings of Power Boring?

Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast

Thomas Mirus, James Majewski, and Nathan Douglas discuss the new Amazon series, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power. The show thus far is not so much offensive as it is bland in ways similar to much popular film and television today. This discussion attempts to understand why the show generally fails to move, focusing especially on its frequent small-mindedness or arbitrariness in characterization and writing, and on its habit of “telegraphing” or signalling emotion rather than genuinely conveying it.

(We apologize for the lip-syncing problems in this episode!)

Topics and timestamps:

0:00 Introduction

3:27 The “Game-of-Thronesification” of character motivation

9:34 Galadriel, Valinor, and the elves’ artistic motivations

18:01 A graceless Galadriel and small-minded writing

29:02 Contrasting performances: Galadriel vs. Elrond

35:21 Failure to trust that virtue is interesting

37:59 “IT’S A SNOW TROOOOOOLL!” The “John-Wickification” of action

41:00 Generic tough girl face; telegraphing emotion rather than living it

52:44 Arbitrary conflict and fussy dwarves

59:06 Starting at level 1: the “video-gamification” of character development

1:06:00 Too much harfoot-talk: cliché TV dialogue with a hobbity skin

1:15:09 The political conversation around the show

1:25:40 Shallow and arbitrary diversity is self-defeating

1:37:07 Erasing womanhood in the pursuit of “strong female characters”

Links

Read Nathan Douglas's film writing here https://vocationofcinema.substack.com

Music is The Duskwhales, “Take It Back”, used with permission. https://theduskwhales.bandcamp.com

This podcast is a production of CatholicCulture.org. If you like the show, please consider supporting us! http://catholicculture.org/donate/audio