68: Israel Keyes & The Murder of Samantha Koenig

Insomniacs: The Podcast

This week, we’re diving into the heartbreaking story of Samantha Koenig and how her murder led to the capture of one of the most terrifying serial killers in modern history: Israel Keyes.

Samantha was an 18-year-old with a big heart and an even bigger personality, working at a coffee stand in Anchorage, Alaska, when her life was tragically cut short. Her abduction and murder would eventually unravel Keyes’ dark, twisted secrets—secrets that included a horrifying trail of victims and “kill kits” buried across the country.

We’ll talk about Samantha’s life, the awful events of her abduction, and how Keyes’ arrogance helped law enforcement finally track him down. Along the way, we’ll get into just how calculated and terrifying Keyes was, why he’s so different from other killers, and how Samantha’s case changed everything.
It’s a story that’s heartbreaking, horrifying, and almost unbelievable—but one you won’t want to miss. Although be prepared- it's also a case that's sure to keep you up at night.
Stay spooky. Stay safe. And sweet dreams!

Sources:
Biography.com- Israel Keyes
FBI- Israel Keyes Evidence
Wiki- Israel Keyes
CBS News- Israel Keyes
FBI Vault- Israel Keyes
AE TV- Serial Killer Israel Keyes
Samantha Koenig Case
Samantha Koenig

To Stay Up To Date On Future Episodes:
Instagram: InsomniacsThePodcast
Facebook: Insomniacs: The Podcast Discussion Group
Tik Tok: Insomniacs.Pod