#287 The Birds, the Bees, and the Budget: Free Contraception For Under 17?

The Niall Boylan Podcast (They Told Me To Shut Up)

In this episode, Niall is asking, has the State crossed the line offering free contraception to under-17s? The debate stems from the news that Health Minister Stephen Donnelly is pushing to expand free contraception to 16-year-olds as part of Budget 2025. Currently, free contraception is available for women aged 17-35, but extending it to under-16s has sparked concerns about mixed messages from the government, especially given that the age of consent in Ireland is 17. Some argue it will encourage underage sexual activity, while others see it as necessary harm reduction.

Some callers think this is absolutely crossing a line. Providing free contraception to girls under 16 sends the wrong message. They argue these kids aren’t emotionally ready for sexual relationships, and by giving them contraception, the government is implicitly endorsing the behavior. These callers feel the focus should be on education and understanding the risks and consequences of sexual activity, not making it easier for teens to engage in it. To them, this initiative sends a dangerously confusing message about consent and responsibility.

While other callers feel teens are already having sex, and it’s time to face that reality. Providing contraception to under-16s is about harm reduction, not permission. These callers argue that it’s better to ensure young people are safe and protected rather than dealing with more teenage pregnancies or sexually transmitted diseases. They agree that education should be a crucial part of this initiative but feel denying contraception won’t stop teens from being sexually active—it will just make them more vulnerable.

As Niall concludes, he reflects on the complex nature of the debate. While it's clear that there are strong feelings on both sides, the challenge remains in finding a balance between protecting young people and addressing the realities they face. Ultimately, it’s about whether the government’s role should be focused on harm reduction or enforcing moral guidelines. What’s clear is that the issue of free contraception for under-17s taps into deeper concerns about education, responsibility, and the evolving nature of parenting and state intervention in Ireland.